4 Extremely Useful Tips To Make The Right Hiring Decision

4 Extremely Useful Tips To Make The Right Hiring Decision

In the rapidly evolving world of early childhood education, hiring the right professionals is critical. It's a well-documented fact that the early years are crucial for child development. According to the Harvard Center on the Developing Child, the first few years of life can affect everything from educational attainment to lifelong health. Therefore, the role of educators in these formative years is pivotal. Making the right hiring decision goes beyond examining résumés - it involves multiple layers of screening, validation, and alignment with the core values and mission of your institution.

Discover these four game-changing, research-validated strategies to revolutionize your early education center's hiring process. These aren't just tips; they're your blueprint for success in making the most impactful hiring decisions of your career. Act now to secure the best educators who will shape the next generation.

Clearly Define Job Roles and Expectations

Why Behavioral Fit Makes a Real Difference

Let's talk about why clarity in job roles is so pivotal. A study in the 'International Journal of Selection and Assessment' turned the spotlight on something many of us might overlook - how clearly defined job expectations can actually predict how well someone will do their job. In simpler terms, if you tell folks exactly what you expect from them, they're more likely to meet or even exceed those expectations. That’s a win-win for everyone, especially when we’re talking about shaping the future of little ones.

The Nuts and Bolts of a Great Job Description

Imagine you’re building a LEGO tower. You wouldn't start without a blueprint, right? A job description acts in much the same way - it's the blueprint for the candidate and the employer.

  • Qualifications and Skills: List out the non-negotiables like a degree in early childhood education, first-aid certifications, or a set number of years of experience.
  • Day-to-Day Responsibilities: Whether it’s planning curricula or making sure nap time goes off without a hitch, be upfront about what a typical day looks like. No one likes surprises, especially not when it involves a room full of toddlers.
  • Organizational Culture: If your center has a philosophy or a specific educational approach like Montessori or Waldorf, say so.
  • Expected Outcomes: Outline goals and key performance indicators, whether it's child engagement levels or parent satisfaction rates.

The more detailed you are, the more likely you'll attract candidates who think, “Yes, this is exactly the job I’ve been looking for!”

Specific Traits for Early Childhood Education

Kids aren’t just tiny adults. Their brains are like sponges, forming impressions and attitudes that will stick with them for life. That's why certain qualities in educators are non-negotiable:

  • Patience: The ability to keep your cool when everyone’s crying or refusing to share toys is more golden than anything you'll find at the end of a rainbow.
  • Creativity: Whether turning a cardboard box into a castle or teaching the alphabet through a song, a creative approach can make learning feel like play.
  • Strong Communication Skills: You’re not just talking to kids; you're also dealing with parents, colleagues, and sometimes even regulators. Being clear and compassionate in your communication makes everything easier.

Following Statutory Requirements

Remember, you’re not just running a daycare; you’re running a learning center that needs to comply with state and national standards. The National Association for the Education of Young Children (NAEYC) has guidelines on what qualifications early childhood professionals should have. For example, they may recommend that lead teachers have at least a bachelor’s degree in early childhood education or a related field. These aren't just hoops to jump through; they're measures to ensure that children are receiving quality care and education.

The next time you're looking to hire, remember that a well-crafted, explicit job description isn’t bureaucratic red tape; it's your first step toward finding the perfect match for your team.

Leverage Behavioral Interviews and Analytics

Why Behavioral Fit Makes a Real Difference
So, let's talk numbers for a moment: The Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) has found that employees who really "fit" with their roles have a whopping 36% better job performance. That's like the difference between a car that gets you to your destination safely and one that gives you heated seats, a smooth ride, and killer gas mileage. When people's natural behaviors align with their job requirements, they don't just do the job; they excel at it. In the context of early childhood education, we're talking about teachers who not only educate but inspire, manage classrooms effectively, and build lasting relationships with parents.

Finding that "perfect fit" isn't just luck or intuition; there's a science to it. By taking a structured approach to interviews and leaning a little on technology to understand behavioral traits, you're setting yourself up for a winning match. And when teachers excel, it's not just them who win. It's the kids they're educating, their anxious parents, and, let's be honest, your own peace of mind knowing you've got a rockstar team.

The Magic of Structured Interviews

We've all been in job interviews that felt like casual conversations. They're pleasant, sure, but do they tell us what we need to know? Not always. Research actually shows that structured interviews - where each candidate is asked the same set of specific, role-related questions - are twice as effective in predicting job performance.

For example, rather than asking generic questions like, "Why do you want to work here?" you could ask:

  • "Tell us about a time you had to adapt your teaching approach for a child with different learning needs. What did you do, and what was the outcome?"
  • "How do you handle communication with parents, especially when there’s sensitive feedback involved?"
  • These questions give candidates the chance to demonstrate their practical experience and problem-solving abilities, helping you get a clear sense of how they'll perform in real-world scenarios.

A Little Help from Behavioral Assessment Tools

In comes the techy part, but don’t let that scare you. Tools like the Predictive Index Behavioral Assessment are shortcuts to understanding how someone is likely to act in different situations. It’s a bit like having a crystal ball that shows whether a candidate is likely to be patient during stressful moments or proactive in creating learning opportunities.

Here’s how it works: Candidates take a short online quiz that analyzes key behavioral traits like dominance, patience, formality, and extraversion. The results can then be matched against the profile of your ideal candidate based on what you already know works well in your specific setting.

These tools can be eye-opening. You might find that a candidate who looks great on paper may not actually be a good fit behaviorally for a high-stress, multitasking role like early childhood education - or vice versa.

Include a Practical Component: The Skinny on Why and How

Imagine buying a car without test-driving it. Sounds risky, right? Well, hiring a teacher without observing their real-world skills is a bit like that. A study in the journal 'Teaching and Teacher Education' tells us that seeing is believing - or, more accurately, predicting. It shows that you get the best sense of a teacher’s abilities by watching them in action. Resumes can't capture everything, and nothing beats seeing someone interact with kids or parents to get a full picture of their competence.

Mock Lessons: The Classroom Test Drive

Here’s a simple but powerful idea: Ask the candidate to prepare a 20-minute mock lesson. But don’t make it a "gotcha" moment; give them enough heads-up and context so they can genuinely show their skills.

Why is this so telling? Well, you'll get to see how well they plan, how they engage with imaginary students, and even how they handle the unexpected, like a 'disruptive student' (hello, role-playing!). You’ll quickly get a sense of whether they can make learning fun and accessible, which is the bread and butter of early childhood education.

Parent-Teacher Interaction: The People Skills Check

Every teacher will tell you that educating young kids isn’t just about what happens in the classroom; it’s also about building relationships with parents. And since 70% of parents, according to Pew Research, have concerns about their child's preschool education, effective communication is critical.

Role-play a parent-teacher meeting. Maybe the 'parent' has concerns about their child not sharing well or falling behind in learning numbers. This gives you a chance to see how the candidate addresses concerns, explains their approach, and builds trust. It’s like a sneak peek into their people skills, empathy, and professionalism.

Compliance Understanding: Knowing the Rule Book

When it comes to childcare, the rulebook isn’t just a bunch of fine print - it's a set of laws and guidelines designed to keep kids safe and ensure quality education. And this rulebook can vary quite a bit from state to state.

Consider asking your candidate about state-specific child care regulations and laws. You might ask them to outline the steps they would take if they suspected a child was facing neglect at home or how they'd handle a medical emergency, like an allergic reaction. This checks their awareness and understanding of serious issues that require following legal procedures.

So, why should you care about all these real-world tests and observations? Because teaching young kids is a hands-on, multifaceted job. From designing engaging lessons to handling sensitive conversations with parents to knowing the rules like the back of their hand, the best candidates are those who can juggle all these balls smoothly. And the best way to find out if they can? See them in action.

Consider Cultural Fit and Soft Skills: Why It’s Not Just Fluff

The Hidden Cost of a Bad Fit
Ever bought a pair of shoes that looked amazing but never quite felt right? That's what a bad cultural fit feels like - it might seem fine at first, but it starts to pinch over time. According to Harvard Business Review, a staggering 80% of employee turnover comes from goof-ups made during the hiring process, including failing to spot a poor cultural fit. In early childhood education, where teamwork and alignment with the center's values are vital, a misfit isn't just inconvenient; it can impact the quality of education and care the children receive.

Two Heads (or More) Are Better Than One: Team Feedback

One of the best ways to assess cultural fit is to involve your existing team in the interview process. They can offer valuable perspectives that you might not see because, hey, we've all got our blind spots. Multiple viewpoints give you a fuller picture of how well the candidate meshes with your organization's values and work environment.

For instance, after a candidate’s interview or mock lesson, gather your team for a quick huddle. Ask questions like, "Do you think they’d fit well with our teaching philosophy?" or "How do you feel they'd handle the daily stresses of our fast-paced environment?" The feedback will not only reduce individual biases but also help you make a more informed decision.

Measuring the 'Unmeasurable': Soft Skills Assessment

Here's the thing - hard skills like lesson planning or curriculum development can be taught, but soft skills? They're a part of who you are. Traits like empathy, adaptability, and communication skills are often considered 'soft,' but they’re anything but soft when it comes to their impact.

One approach is to use the Emotional Intelligence Appraisal, a tool trusted by organizations like FedEx and the U.S. Air Force. While it might sound like corporate mumbo-jumbo, this straightforward online quiz can provide insights into emotional intelligence, which is a big deal in a profession where you're shaping tiny humans.

The appraisal assesses things like self-awareness, social awareness, and relationship management. Knowing where a candidate stands on these parameters can help you better understand if they have the emotional chops to manage a classroom, build healthy relationships with parents, and work well with colleagues.

When hiring in early childhood education, or, any field, hard skills are just the tip of the iceberg. Cultural fit and soft skills are the massive, unseen chunks below the surface that can either sink your ship or keep you sailing smoothly. So, don't gloss over them. Use team feedback and proven assessment tools to ensure you're bringing on board someone who's not just capable but also a great fit for your team.


So, we've dug deep into the crucial aspects of making an informed hiring decision in early childhood education - a field that has far-reaching implications for our future. This is not merely an HR exercise; it's a societal responsibility. We've talked about the unignorable stats, the scientific methods, the nuanced assessments, and the softer, more human aspects of hiring. Why? Because nothing less will suffice.

Every single hiring decision you make has a ripple effect that extends far beyond the interview room. It impacts young lives, influences parental peace of mind, and shapes the very culture and effectiveness of your educational setting. A poor hiring decision doesn't just create a hole; it can create a vacuum that sucks energy, morale, and performance out of your team and educational environment. Contrastingly, a good hire is like a force multiplier: someone who amplifies the quality of education fosters a healthy workplace culture, and elevates your organization to new heights.

When choosing someone to mold the next generation, there's no room for error. The stakes are sky-high, but the good news is you're not shooting in the dark. You have strategies, tools, and best practices to make choices that are not just good but transformative.

When shaping the future—our children—it truly takes a village.

Happy hiring!

Want to brush up on best practices? If you’re based in Colorado, ELV offers free access to the ECE Shared Resources Platform. Register Here.

Are you looking for more child care management information? Check out our Ultimate Guide to Child Care Management.

Our child care management system makes running your child care program simple and efficient. Get back to what's most important. You shouldn't have to spend more time on the administrative tasks than you do with children and staff. 

Get the latest and greatest child care news and information today! Sign up for our newsletter...

Or schedule a demo with us to learn more about how our child care management system, Alliance Core, can streamline your administrative processes.

Do you run an early childhood association made up of child care providers? If so, check out our Ultimate Guide to Shared Service Alliance.

Header image courtesy of Pixelied.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top